Comparison

SA-5 Gammon vs SA-10 Grumble in DCS

In DCS the SA-5 Gammon reaches farther than the SA-10 Grumble: 138 nm (255 km) against 65 nm (120 km). The SA-5 Gammon tracks aircraft farther: 184 nm (340 km) against 73 nm (136 km) for the SA-10 Grumble. The SA-5 Gammon reaches higher: 131,200 ft (40,000 m) against 82,000 ft (25,000 m) for the SA-10 Grumble.

They are the two longest-reaching Soviet-designed SAMs in DCS, one static and one mobile.

DCS 2.9.30.28738 · · DCS model values, not real-world performance · How we read DCS data

Side by side

FigureSA-5SA-10
Launch zone9.2–138 nm (17–255 km)SA-52.7–65 nm (5.0–120 km)SA-10LN
Track184 nm (340 km)SA-5 TR73 nm (136 km)SA-10TR
Search81 nm (150 km)SA-5 SR108 nm (200 km)SA-10SR
Missile altitude980–131,200 ft (300–40,000 m)5V28 (SA-5 Gammon)80–82,000 ft (25–25,000 m)5V55 S-300PS (SA-10B Grumble)
Missiles ready6Whole site24Whole site
MobilityStaticMobile
GuidanceSemi-active radarSemi-active radar
RWR and HARM code“5” · HARM 129, “TS” · HARM 130SA-5 TR and SA-5 SR“BB” · HARM 104, “CS” · HARM 103, “10” · HARM 110SA-10SR, SA-10SR(L) and SA-10TR
Reaction time3 s0.1 s
Kill to stop every launcherSA-5 TRSA-10SR(L), SA-10C2 or SA-10TR

That launch zone is a DCS firing rule, not a missile fly-out range or a no-escape zone.

What changes for your route

  • Stay 73 nm (135 km) farther from the SA-5 Gammon than from the SA-10 Grumble to remain outside its launch zone.
  • Above 82,000 ft (25,000 m) you overfly the SA-10 Grumble. Only the SA-5 Gammon can still reach you there.
  • Below 980 ft (300 m) you underfly the SA-5 Gammon. The SA-10 Grumble engages down to 80 ft (25 m).
  • Every launcher of the SA-5 Gammon depends on the SA-5 TR: kill it and the site cannot fire.
  • Every launcher of the SA-10 Grumble depends on the SA-10SR(L), the SA-10C2 and the SA-10TR: kill any one and the site cannot fire.
  • The SA-10 Grumble is mobile and can relocate. The SA-5 Gammon is static.

Questions

Which has the longer range in DCS, the SA-5 Gammon or the SA-10 Grumble?

In DCS the SA-5 Gammon reaches farther than the SA-10 Grumble: 138 nm (255 km) against 65 nm (120 km). That launch zone is a DCS firing rule, not a missile fly-out range or a no-escape zone.

Which tracks aircraft farther in DCS, the SA-5 Gammon or the SA-10 Grumble?

The SA-5 Gammon tracks aircraft farther: 184 nm (340 km) against 73 nm (136 km) for the SA-10 Grumble.

Which reaches higher in DCS, the SA-5 Gammon or the SA-10 Grumble?

The SA-5 Gammon reaches higher: 131,200 ft (40,000 m) against 82,000 ft (25,000 m) for the SA-10 Grumble.

How do the SA-5 Gammon and the SA-10 Grumble show on your RWR?

On the SA-5 Gammon, the SA-5 TR shows as “5” (HARM code 129) and the SA-5 SR shows as “TS” (HARM code 130). On the SA-10 Grumble, the SA-10SR shows as “BB” (HARM code 104), the SA-10SR(L) shows as “CS” (HARM code 103) and the SA-10TR shows as “10” (HARM code 110).

Which has more missiles ready in DCS, the SA-5 Gammon or the SA-10 Grumble?

The SA-10 Grumble: 24 missiles ready per site against 6 for the SA-5 Gammon.